1959
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Don Allard | QB | Boston College |
| Emil Karas | T | Dayton |
| Jim Wood | E | Oklahoma St. |
| Bob Wetoska | T | Notre Dame |
| Jim McFalls | T | VMI |
| Don Lawrence | T | Notre Dame |
| Mitch Ogiego | QB | Iowa |
| Jim Kenney | E | Boston |
| Gene O'pella | E | Villanova |
| Dick Haley | B | Pittsburgh |
| Ron Togh | B | Notre Dame |
| Gerry Marciniak | G | Michigan |
| Roger Wypyszynski | T | St. Norbert |
| Billy Shoemake | E | LSU |
| Kurt Schwarz | G | Maryland |
| Fred Hood | E | N.E. Oklahoma |
| Dick Splain | T | New Haven |
| Jim Healy | G | Holy Cross |
| Joe Kapp | QB | California |
| Bobby Lauder | B | Auburn |
| Billy Brewer | B | Mississippi |
| Mel Reight | B | West Virginia |
| Art Gob | E | Pittsburgh |
| Clarence Alexander | B | S.E. LA |
| George Darrah | B | F&M |
| Bob Sargent | T | Colby |
| Gene Grabosky | T | Syracuse |
| Norm Odyniec | B | Notre Dame |
| Billy Austin | B | Rutgers |
| Don Lockwood | G | Tulane |
| Jim Colclough | B | Boston College |
1958
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Mike Sommer | B | G.W. |
| Stan Flowers | B | Georgia Tech |
| Bill Anderson | B | Tennessee |
| Dan Nolan | QB | Lehigh |
| Jim Van Pelt | QB | Michigan |
| Dick Lynch | B | Notre Dame |
| Leon Bennett | T | Boston College |
| Buddy Payne | E | North Carolina |
| Frank Kuchta | C | Notre Dame |
| Ben Preston | T | Auburn |
| Darrell Dess | T | N.C. St. |
| Eddie Michaels | G | Villanova |
| Ken Ford | QB | Hardin-Simmons |
| Jack Faris | E | Penn St. |
| Jack Davis | T | Arizona |
| Fred Polzer | E | Virginia |
| Fred Wilt | T | Richmond |
| Lennie King | B | Connecticut |
| Don Stephenson | C | Georgia Tech |
| Lou Pelham | E | Florida |
| Jackie Simpson | G | Mississippi |
| Charley Sanders | B | W. Texas St. |
| Ron Schomburger | E | Florida St. |
| Rod Hanson | E | Illinois |
| John Groom | G | TCU |
| Frank Bloomquist | G | Iowa |
| Perry Gehring | E | Minnesota |
| Joe Biggs | G | Hardin-Simmons |
| Ed Coffin | B | Syracuse |
| Ted Smith | E | Georgia Tech |
1957
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Don Bosseler | B | Miami |
| Joe Walton | E | Pittsburgh |
| Eddie Sutton | B | North Carolina |
| Jim Podoley | B | Central Michigan |
| J.T. Frankenberger | T | Kentucky |
| Wally Merz | T | Colorado |
| Paul Lopata | B | Central Michigan |
| Galen Laack | G | Pacific |
| Don Dobrino | B | Iowa |
| Dick Foster | T | Idaho |
| Wade Mitchell | QB | Georgia Tech |
| Claude Austin | B | G.W. |
| George Rice | T | Wofford |
| Brad Bomba | E | Indiana |
| Joe Brodsky | B | Florida |
| Fred Brock | B | Wheaton |
| Ed Sakach | G | G.W. |
| John Bauer | B | Villanova |
| Buddy Frick | E | South Carolina |
| Sam Owen | B | Georgia Tech |
| Ed Voytek | G | Purdue |
| Al Viola | G | Northwestern |
| Bob Jennings | C | Furman |
| Dick Sassels | T | Catawba |
| Paul Rotenberry | B | Georgia Tech |
| Ormand Anderson | T | Georgia Tech |
| Guy Martin | B | Colgate |
| George Benedict | E | Springfield |
| Art Luppino | B | Arizona |
1956
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Ed Vereb | B | Maryland |
| John Paluck | E | Pittsburgh |
| Fred Wyant | B | West Virginia |
| Fran Machinsky | T | Ohio St. |
| Gary Lowe | B | Michigan St. |
| Donnie Caraway | B | Houston |
| Dick James | B | Oregon |
| Whitey Rouviere | B | Miami |
| Tom Powell | G | Colgate |
| Gerry Planutis | B | Michigan St. |
| Jerry Ward | G | Dayton |
| Pat Uebel | B | Army |
| Wells Gray | G | Wisconsin |
| Eagle Day | QB | Mississippi |
| Jim Pyburn | E | Auburn |
| Ray Lemak | G | Notre Dame |
| Vince Gonzalez | B | LSU |
| Howard Schnellenberger | E | Kentucky |
| George Nicula | T | Notre Dame |
| Don St. John | B | Xavier |
| Johnny Tatum | C | Texas |
| Franklin Brooks | G | Georgia Tech |
| Dave Burnham | B | Wheaton |
| Royce Flippin | B | Princeton |
| Billy Hicks | B | Alabama |
| Pat Bisceglia | G | Notre Dame |
| Buck Mystrom | G | Michigan St. |
1955
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Ralph Guglielmi | QB | Notre Dame |
| Ray Perkins | B | Syracuse |
| Don Glantz | T | Nebraska |
| Eric Christensen | E | Richmond |
| Ron Marciniak | G | Kansas St. |
| Johnny Allen | C | Purdue |
| John Miller | T | Boston College |
| Tom Louderback | G | San Jose St. |
| Larry Parker | B | North Carolina |
| John Barish | T | Waynesburg |
| Len Oniskey | T | Cornell |
| Tom Braatz | E | Marquette |
| Charley Horton | B | Vanderbilt |
| Hal Norris | B | California |
| Don Shea | G | Georgia |
| Don Bailey | B | Penn St. |
| Bob Dee | E | Holy Cross |
| Ron Geyer | T | Michigan |
| Buck George | B | Clemson |
| Joe Boland | B | G.W. |
| Chick Donaldson | C | West Virginia |
| Bob Ready | T | Notre Dame |
| Frank Radella | C | Wyoming |
| Walt Houston | G | Purdue |
| A.J. Baker | B | Arkansas |
| Arch Cassidy | T | Florida |
| Bing Bordier | E | USC |
| Tom Petty | E | Virginia Tech |
1954
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Steve Mellinger | E | Kentucky |
| Jim Schrader | C | Notre Dame |
| Ralph Felton | B | Maryland |
| Billy Wells | B | Michigan St. |
| Bill McHenry | C | Wash. & Lee |
| Harry Jagielski | T | Indiana |
| Bill Marker | E | West Virginia |
| Jerry Minnick | T | Nebraska |
| Merrill Green | B | Oklahoma |
| Gene Wilson | B | South Carolina |
| Ben Dunkerly | T | West Virginia |
| Roger Dornburg | B | Wisconsin |
| Roger Nelson | T | Oklahoma |
| Hugh Merck | T | South Carolina |
| Gilmer Spring | E | Texas |
| Jerry Coody | B | Baylor |
| Walt Cudzik | C | Purdue |
| Jerry Witt | B | Wisconsin |
| Sam Morley | E | Stanford |
| John Cavaglieri | T | N. Texas St. |
| Max Schmaling | B | Purdue |
| Pete Carrieri | G | Villanova |
| Will Renfro | E | Memphis St. |
| George Rosso | G | Ohio St. |
| Dorsey Gibson | B | Okla. St. |
| Ken Yarborough | E | North Carolina |
| Ron Hansen | T | Minnesota |
| Ted Kress | B | Michigan |
| Don Rondou | Northwestern |
1953
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Jack Scarbath | B | Maryland |
| Dick Modzelewski | T | Maryland |
| Paul Dekker | E | Michigan St. |
| Don Boll | G | Nebraska |
| Nick Carras | B | Missouri |
| Lew Weidensaul | E | Maryland |
| Alex Webster | B | N.C. State |
| Buzz Nutter | C | Virginia Tech |
| Ed Timmerman | B | Michigan St. |
| Dave Suminski | T | Wisconsin |
| Jim Slay | E | Mississippi |
| Bob Haner | B | Villanova |
| Jim Turner | B | Texas Tech |
| Tom Flyzik | T | G.W. |
| Bill Link | G | Wake Forest |
| Jim Dublinski | C | Utah |
| Ed Pucci | G | USC |
| Ed Bierne | E | Detroit |
| Stan Butterworth | B | Bucknall |
| Art Hurd | G | Maryland |
| Walt Ashcraft | T | USC |
| John Zanetti | T | John Carroll |
| Bob Buckley | B | USC |
| Pat Shires | B | Tennessee |
| Bob Mathias | B | Stanford |
1952
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Larry Isbell | B | Baylor |
| Andy Davis | B | G.W. |
| Al Dorow | B | Michigan St. |
| Dick Hightower | C | SMU |
| Jim Clark | G | Oregon St. |
| Ed Kensler | G | Maryland |
| Vic Janowicz | B | Ohio St. |
| Hubert Johnston | T | Iowa |
| Dick Alban | B | Northwestern |
| Chet Ostrowski | E | Notre Dame |
| Orlanda Mazza | E | Michigan St. |
| Frank Middendorf | C | Cincinnati |
| Ray Potter | T | LSU |
| Doug Conway | T | TCU |
| Julius Wittman | T | Ohio St. |
| Marv Berschet | T | Illinois |
| Bill Bocetti | B | Wash. & Lee |
| Ed Bartlett | E | California |
| Joe Marvin | B | UCLA |
| Roger Kinson | C | Missouri |
| Dick Jenkins | T | Illinois |
| Jim O'rourke | B | N.C. St. |
| Ken Barfield | T | Mississippi |
| Ted Kirkland | T | Vanderbilt |
| Sal Gero | T | Elon |
| Danny Goode | B | Hardin-Simmons |
| Ben White | E | SMU |
| Ron Engel | B | Minnesota |
| John Pappa | B | California |
| Bob Linn | B | Case Western |
1951
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Leon Heath | B | Oklahoma |
| Eddie Salem | B | Alabama |
| Jim Staton | T | Wake Forest |
| Walt Yowarsky | T | Kentucky |
| Paul Giroski | T | Rice |
| Jonn Martinkovic | E | Xavier |
| Jonny Papit | B | Virginia |
| Billy Cox | B | Duke |
| Jake Rowden | C | Maryland |
| Bob Jensen | E | Iowa St. |
| Bill DeChard | B | Holy Cross |
| Al Applegate | G | Scranton |
| Dick Campbell | B | Wyoming |
| Adrian Burk | QB | Baylor |
| Vic Thomas | T | Colorado |
| Bob Bates | C | Texas A&M |
| Gene Brito | E | Loyola (Ca.) |
| Dom Fucci | B | Kentucky |
| Buddy Brown | G | Arkansas |
| John Krestes | B | Purdue |
| Clarence Marable | T | TCU |
| Elliot Speed | C | Alabama |
| Cecil Martin | B | N. Texas St. |
| Tom Powers | B | Duke |
| Bob Chubb | E | Shippensburg |
| Johnny Williams | B | USC |
| Bill Johnson | B | Stetson |
| John Kadiec | G | Missouri |
| Bart Stewart | B | S.E. Oklahoma |
| Nick Bolkovac | T | Pittsburgh |
1950
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| George Thomas | B | Oklahoma |
| Hally Haynes | B | Santa Clara |
| Lou Karras | T | Purdue |
| Harry Ulinski | C | Kentucky |
| Frank Spaniel | B | Notre Dame |
| Gene Pepper | G | Missouri |
| Jerry Houghton | T | Wash. St. |
| John Rohde | E | Pacific |
| Don Winslow | T | Iowa |
| Eddie LeBaron | QB | Pacific |
| Dan Brown | E | Villanova |
| Bill Chauncey | B | Iowa St. |
| Clay Davis | C | Oklahoma St. |
| Lyle Button | T | Illinois |
| Alex Lloyd | E | Oklahoma St. |
| Charlie Justice | B | North Carolina |
| Jim Cullom | G | California |
| Alvin Duke | B | Arkansas |
| Ed White | E | Alabama |
| George Bayer | T | Washington |
| Cas Witucki | G | Indiana |
| John DeLaurentis | T | Waynesburg |
| Joe Zuravieff | E | Northwestern |
| Dick Tilton | T | Nevada |
| Art Stewart | B | S.E. Oklahoma |
| Earl Roth | B | Maryland |
| Ed Lee | T | Kansas |
| Ralph Shoaf | B | West Virginia |
| Johnny Lundin | G | Minnesota |
| Bob Noppinger | E | Georgetown |
