1969
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Eugene Epps | DB | UTEP |
| Ed Cross | RB | Arkansas-Pine Bluff |
| Bill Kishman | DB | Colorado St. |
| Harold McLinton | LB | Southern |
| Jeff Anderson | RB | Virginia |
| John Didion | C | Oregon St. |
| Larry Brown | RB | Kansas St. |
| Eric Norri | DT | Notre Dame |
| Bob Shannon | DB | Tennessee St. |
| Mike Shook | DB | North Texas St. |
| Rick Brand | DT | Virginia |
| Paul Rogers | T | Virginia |
| Mike Washington | LB | Southern |
| Rich Dobbert | DE | Springfield |
1968
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Yazoo Smith | DB | Oregon |
| Tom Roussel | LB | Southern Miss. |
| Dennis Crane | DT | USC |
| Ken Barefoot | TE | Virginia Tech |
| Mike Bragg | K | Richmond |
| Willie Banks | G | Alcorn St. |
| Bob Brunet | RB | LSU |
| Brian Magnuson | RB | Montana |
| Frank Liberatore | DB | Clemson |
| Tom Garretson | DB | Northwestern |
| Dave Weedman | DT | W. Washington |
| Mike St. Louis | T | Central Missouri |
| Dave Zivich | T | Cal-Santa Barbara |
| Coger Coverson | G | Texas Southern |
| Willie Turner | RB | Jackson St. |
| Frank Bosch | DT | Colorado |
1967
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Ray McDonald | FB | Idaho |
| Spain Musgrove | DT | Utah St. |
| Curg Belcher | DB | BYU |
| Don Bandy | T | Tulsa |
| Bruce Matte | QB-RB | Miami (Ohio) |
| John Love | FL | North Texas St. |
| Larry Hendershot | G-LB | Arizona St. |
| Pete Larsen | HB | Cornell |
| Tim Houlton | DT | St. Norbert |
| Bruce Sullivan | DB | Illinois |
| Bill Brown | C | UTEP |
| Ron Sepic | E | Ohio St. |
| Bob Rodwell | LB | Eastern Michigan |
| Andy Socha | HB | Marshall |
| Ed Breding | G | Texas A&M |
| Alfredo Avila | DB | Sul Ross |
| Lyle Baucom | T | Cal St.-San Fran. |
1966
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Charlie Gogolak | K | Princeton |
| Walter Barnes | T | Nebraska |
| Tom Barrington | FB | Ohio St. |
| Bill Clay | DB | Mississippi |
| Dick Lemay | T | Vanderbilt |
| Earl Yates | T | Duke |
| George Patton | T | Georgia |
| Stan Mitchell | FB | Tennessee |
| Jack Shinholser | LB | Florida State |
| Caesar Belser | DB | Ark-Monticello |
| Dick Reding | Northwestern St. | |
| John Stipech | LB | Utah |
| Heath Wingate | C | Bowling Green |
| Jerry Lovelace | RB | Texas Tech |
| Hal Seymour | K-RB | Florida |
| Hal Wantland | RB | Tennessee |
| Mitch Zalnasky | E | Pittsburgh |
| Joe Burson | RB | Georgia |
| Andre White | Florida A&M | |
| John Kelly | C | Florida A&M |
1965
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Bob Breitenstein | T | Tulsa |
| Kent McCloughan | B | Nebraska |
| Don Croftcheck | G-LB | Indiana |
| Jerry Smith | E | Arizona State |
| Bob Briggs | FB | Central St. |
| Willie Adams | G | New Mexico St. |
| John Strohmeyer | T | Michigan |
| Biff Bracy | HB | Duke |
| Dave Estrada | HB | Arizona St. |
| Ben Baldwin | B | Vanderbilt |
| Robert Reed | G | Tennessee A&I |
| Gary Hard | E | Vanderbilt |
| Chris Hanburger | LB | North Carolina |
| Roosevelt Ellerbe | B | Iowa St. |
1964
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Charley Taylor | HB | Arizona St. |
| Paul Krause | DB | Iowa |
| Jim Snowden | FB | Notre Dame |
| Russ Brown | E | Florida |
| Dick Shiner | QB | Maryland |
| Len Hauss | C | Georgia |
| Rick Leeson | B | Pittsburgh |
| Gene Donaldson | LB | Purdue |
| Bob Avolerin | T | Tennessee |
| Tom McDonals | B | Notre Dame |
| Tom Urbanik | B | Penn St. |
| Dick Evers | T | Colorado St. |
| Tommy Walters | S | Mississippi |
| Ozzie Clay | B | Iowa St. |
| Bob Jones | G | Nebraska |
| John Seedborg | G | Arizona St. |
| Fordon Guest | B | Arkansas |
1963
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Pat Richter | E | Wisconsin |
| Lonnie Sanders | B | Michigan St. |
| Ron Snidow | T | Oregon |
| Charley Nickoson | T | Ohio |
| Dave Francis | B | Ohio St. |
| Billy Joe | B | Villanova |
| Rod Foster | G | Ohio St. |
| Allen Schau | E | Western Mich. |
| Bob Caldwell | C | Georgia Tech |
| John Greiner | E | Purdue |
| Tom Winingder | B | Georgia Tech |
| Harry Butsko | LB | Maryland |
| Dave Adams | G | Arkansas |
| Ron Whaley | HB | Tenn.-Chattanooga |
| Drew Roberts | E | Cal State-Humboldt |
| Jim Turner | QB | Utah State |
| Joe Baughan | T | Auburn |
1962
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Ernie Davis | B | Syracuse |
| Joe Hernandez | B | Arizona |
| Bob Mitinger | E | Penn St. |
| Billy Neighbors | T | Alabama |
| Bert Coan | HB | Kansas |
| Ron Hatcher | FB | Michigan St. |
| Dave Viti | E | Boston |
| John Childress | G | Arkansas |
| Carl Palazzo | T | Adams St. |
| Terry Terrebonne | HB | Tulane |
| Bill Whisler | E | Iowa |
| Jim Costen | HB | South Carolina |
| Len Velia | T | Georgia |
| Tommy Brooker | E | Alabama |
| Alan Miller | G | Ohio |
| Carl Charon | B | Michigan St. |
| Claude Crabb | B | Colorado |
| Ed Trancygier | QB | Florida St. |
1961
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Norm Snead | QB | Wake Forest |
| Joe Rutgens | T | Illinois |
| Jim Cunningham | B | Pittsburgh |
| Joe Krakoski | B | Illinois |
| John O'Day | T | Miami |
| Jim Kerr | B | Penn St. |
| Charley Barnes | E | N.E. Louisiana |
| Joel Arrington | B | Duke |
| Riley Mattson | T | Oregon |
| Bob Coolbaugh | E | Richmond |
| Doug Emore | B | Mississippi |
| Doyle Schick | B | Kansas |
| Bob Jonson | E | Michigan |
| Ron Petty | T | Louisville |
| Joe Bellino | B | Navy |
| George Tolford | T | Ohio St. |
| Tony Romeo | E | Florida St. |
| Mike Ingram | G | Ohio St. |
1960
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Richie Lucas | QB | Penn St |
| Sam Homer | HB | VMI |
| Andy Stynchula | T | Penn St. |
| Vince Promuto | G | Holy Cross |
| Don Stallings | T | North Carolina |
| Dave Hudson | E | Florida |
| Earl Kohlhaas | G | Penn St. |
| Dwight Bumgarner | E | Dwight Bumgarner |
| Jim Elfrid | C | Colorado St. |
| Jim Crotty | HB | Notre Dame |
| Bill Herron | E | Georgia |
| Charley Milstead | B | Texas A&M |
| Bernie Darre | G | Tulane |
| Joe Kulbacki | B | Purdue |
| Billy Roland | G | Georgia |
| John Lawrence | G | N.C. St. |
| Ron Maltony | G | Purdue |
| Jimmy Wolf | HB | Panhandle St. |
