P
| Name | Position | College | Years Played |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paea, Stephen | DE | Oregon St. | 2015 |
| Paine, Jeff | LB | San Jose St. | 1986 |
| Painter, Vinston | OL | Virginia Tech | 2016 |
| Pakulak, Glenn | P | Kentucky | 2009 |
| Paluck, John | DE | Pittsburgh | 1956, 1959-65 |
| Palmer, Sterling | DE | Florida St. | 1993-96 |
| Papit, John | B | Virginia | 1951-53 |
| Pardee, Jack | LB | Texas A&M | 1971-72 |
| Parks, Mickey | C | Oklahoma | 1938-40 |
| Parrish, Lemar | CB | Lincoln | 1978-81 |
| Pasque, Joe | T | SMU | 1943 |
| Paternoster, Angelo | G | Georgetown | 1943 |
| Patten, David | WR | West Carolina | 2005-06 |
| Patterson, Dimitri | DB | Tuskegee | 2005 |
| Patton, Joe | T | Alabama A&M | 1994-98 |
| Patton, Marvcus | LB | UCLA | 1995-98 |
| Paul, Niles | WR/TE | Nebraska | 2011-17 |
| Paul, Tito | CB | Ohio St. | 1999 |
| Paulescu, Sam | P | Oregon St. | 2010 |
| Paulsen, Logan | TE | UCLA | 2010-15 |
| Peebles, Jim | E | Vanderbilt | 1946-49, 1951 |
| Peete, Rodney | QB | USC | 1999 |
| Peiffer, Dan | C | Southeast Missouri St. | 1980 |
| Pellegrini, Bob | LB | Maryland | 1962-65 |
| Pepper, Gene | G | Missouri | 1950-53 |
| Pergine, John | LB | Notre Dame | 1973-75 |
| Perine, Samaje | RB | Oklahoma | 2017-18 |
| Perrin, Lonnie | RB | Illinois | 1979 |
| Peters, Floyd | T | San Francisco St. | 1970 |
| Peters, Otha | LB | Louisiana-Lafayette | 2017 |
| Peters, Tony | S | Oklahoma | 1979-82, 1984-85 |
| Peters, Volney | T | USC | 1954-57 |
| Peterson, Nelson | RB | West Va. Wesleyan | 1937 |
| Pettey, Phil | G | Missouri | 1987 |
| Petitbon, Richie | S | Tulane | 1971-72 |
| Phillips, Dashaun | CB | Tarleton St. | 2015-16 |
| Phillips, Joe | WR | Kentucky | 1985, 87 |
| Piasecky, Al | E | Duke | 1943-45 |
| Pierce, Antonio | LB | Arizona | 2001-04 |
| Pierce, Dan | RB | Memphis St. | 1970 |
| Pinckert, Ernie | FB | USC | 1932-40 |
| Plackemeier, Ryan | P | Wake Forest | 2008 |
| Planutis, Jerry | B | Michigan St. | 1956 |
| Plummer, Terrance | LB | Central Florida | 2015 |
| Podoley, Jim | RB | Cetral Michigan | 1957-60 |
| Poillon, Dick | B | Canisius | 1942, 1946-49 |
| Polsfoot, Fran | E | Washington St. | 1953 |
| Polumbus, Tyler | T | Colorado | 2011-14 |
| Ponds, Antwaune | LB | Syracuse | 1998 |
| Porter, Tracy | CB | Indiana | 2014 |
| Portis, Clinton | RB | Miami (Fla.) | 2004-10 |
| Posey, Jeff | LB | Southern Miss. | 2006 |
| Potter, John | K | Western Michigan | 2013 |
| Pottios, Myron | LB | Notre Dame | 1971-73 |
| Pounds, Darryl | CB | Nicholls St. | 1995-99 |
| Pourdanesh, Shar | T | Nevada | 1996-98 |
| Powell, Carl | DL | Louisville | 2002 |
| Presley, Lee | C | Oklahoma | 1945 |
| Prestel, Jim | T | Idaho | 1966-67 |
| Prioleau, Pierson | S | Virginia Tech | 2005-07 |
| Promuto, Vince | G | Holy Cross | 1960-70 |
| Pryor Sr., Terrelle | WR | Ohio St. | 2017 |
| Pucillo, Mike | OL | Auburn | 2006-07 |
| Pugh, Jordan | S | Texas A&M | 2012-13 |
| Parris, Timon | OL | Stony Brook | 2018 |
| Payne, Daron | DL | Alabama | 2018 |
| Peterson, Adrian | RB | Oklahoma | 2018 |
