S
| Name | Position | College | Years Played |
|---|---|---|---|
| Saenz, Eddie | RB | USC | 1946-51 |
| Sagnella, Anthony | DT | Rutgers | 1987 |
| Salave'a, Joe | DL | Arizona | 2004-06 |
| Salem, Ed | B | Alabama | 1951 |
| Salter, Bryant | S | Pittsburgh | 1974-75 |
| Sample, Johnny | DB | Maryland St. | 1963-65 |
| Samuels, Chris | T | Alabama | 2000-09 |
| Sanchez, John | T | San Francisco | 1947-49 |
| Sanders, Chris | TE | Texas A&M | 1997 |
| Sanders, Deion | CB | Florida St. | 2000 |
| Sanders, Lonnie | DB | Michigan St. | 1963-67 |
| Sanders, Ricky | WR | SW Texas St. | 1986-93 |
| Sandifer, Dan | DB | LSU | 1948-49 |
| Sanford, Haywood | E | Alabama | 1940 |
| Sanford, Jamarca | S | Ole Miss | 2014 |
| Sarboe, Phil | DB | Washington St. | 1934 |
| Sardisco, Tony | G | Tulane | 1956 |
| Sasa, Don | DT | Washington St. | 1997 |
| Saul, Ron | G | Michigan St. | 1976-81 |
| Savage, Sebastian | CB | North Carolina St. | 1995 |
| Sawyer, John | TE | Southern Miss. | 1983 |
| Scafide, John | T | Tulane | 1933 |
| Scanlan, Jerry | T | Hawaii | 1980-81 |
| Scarbath, Jack | QB | Maryland | 1953-54 |
| Scherff, Brandon | G | Iowa | 2015-18 |
| Schick, Doyle | LB | Kansas | 1961 |
| Schilling, Ralph | E | Oklahoma | 1946 |
| Schlereth, Mark | G | Idaho | 1989-94 |
| Schmidt, Kermit | E | Cal Poly-Pomona | 1932 |
| Schoenke, Ray | G | SMU | 1966-75 |
| Schrader, Jim | C | Notre Dame | 1954, 1956-61 |
| Schroeder, Jay | QB | UCLA | 1984-87 |
| Scissum, Williard | G | Alabama | 1987 |
| Scott, Darrion | DL | Ohio St. | 2010-11 |
| Scott, Greg | DE | Hampton | 2002 |
| Scott, Jake | S | Georgia | 1976-78 |
| Scotti, Ben | DB | Maryland | 1959-61 |
| Scudero, Joe | B | San Francisco | 1954-58 |
| Scully, Mike | C | Illinois | 1988 |
| Seals, George | G | Missouri | 1964 |
| Seay, Virgil | WR | Troy St. | 1981-84 |
| Sebek, Nick | B | Indiana | 1950 |
| Sedoris, Chris | C | Purdue | 1996 |
| Seedborg, John | E | Arizona St. | 1965 |
| Sellers, Mike | FB | Walla Walla | 1998-00, 2004-11 |
| Seno, Frank | B | George Wash. | 1943-44, 1949 |
| Serwanga, Kato | CB | California | 2001 |
| Settles, Tony | LB | Elon | 1987 |
| Severson, Jeff | DB | Long Beach St. | 1972 |
| Seymour, Bob | B | Oklahoma | 1940-45 |
| Shade, Sam | S | Alabama | 1999-02 |
| Sharp, Everett | T | California Tech | 1944-45 |
| Shedd, Kenny | WR | Northern Iowa | 2000 |
| Shepard, Derrick | WR | Oklahoma | 1987-88 |
| Shepherd, Bill | FB | Western Maryland | 1935 |
| Shepherd, Leslie | WR | Temple | 1994-98 |
| Shiner, Dick | QB | Maryland | 1964-66 |
| Shoener, Herb | E | Iowa | 1948-49 |
| Shorter, Jim | DB | Detroit | 1964-67 |
| Shugart, Clyde | G | Iowa St. | 1939-44 |
| Shula, Don | DB | John Carroll | 1957 |
| Shuler, Heath | QB | Tennessee | 1994-96 |
| Siano, Tony | C | Fordham | 1932 |
| Siegert, Herb | G | Illinois | 1949-51 |
| Siemering, Larry | C | San Francisco | 1935-36 |
| Simmons, Ed | T | Eastern Washington | 1987-97 |
| Simmons, Roy | G | Georgia Tech | 1983 |
| Simon, John | RB | Louisiana Tech | 2003 |
| Simpson, Chad | RB | Morgan St. | 2010 |
| Sims, Keith | G | Iowa St. | 1997-00 |
| Sinclair, Matt | LB | Illinois | 2007 |
| Sinko, Steve | T | Duquesne | 1934-36 |
| Sistrunk, Manny | DT | Arkansas AM&N | 1970-75 |
| Skaggs, Justin | WR | Evangel | 2002 |
| Slivinski, Steve | G | Washington | 1939-43 |
| Smith, Alex | TE | Stanford | 2015 |
| Smith, Ben | E | Alabama | 1937 |
| Smith, Bruce | DE | Virginia Tech | 2000-03 |
| Smith, Cedric | FB | Florida | 1994-95 |
| Smith, Clifton | LB | Syracuse | 2003 |
| Smith, Derek M | LB | Arizona St. | 1997-00 |
| Smith, Dick | DB | Northwestern | 1967-68 |
| Smith, Ed | FB | NYU | 1936 |
| Smith, George | C | California | 1937, 1941-43 |
| Smith, Hunter | P | Notre Dame | 2009-10 |
| Smith, Hugh | E | Kansas | 1962 |
| Smith, Jack | E | Stanford | 1943 |
| Smith, Jerry | TE | Arizona St. | 1965-77 |
| Smith, Jim | DB | Oregon | 1968 |
| Smith, Jimmy | RB | Elon | 1984 |
| Smith, John | WR | North Texas St. | 1978 |
| Smith, Larry | RB | Florida | 1974 |
| Smith, Paul | DE | New Mexico | 1979-80 |
| Smith, Ricky | CB | Alabama St. | 1984 |
| Smith, Riley | QB | Alabama | 1936-38 |
| Smith, Preston | LB | Mississippi St. | 2015-18 |
| Smith, Timmy | RB | Texas Tech | 1987-88 |
| Smith, Vernice | G | Florida A&M | 1993-95 |
| Smith, Willie | T | East Carolina | 2011 |
| Smithson, Fish | S | Kansas | 2017 |
| Smoot, Fred | FB | Miss. St. | 2001-04, 2007-08 |
| Snead, Norm | QB | Wake Forest | 1961-63 |
| Sneddon, Bob | B | St. Mary's (CA) | 1944 |
| Snidow, Ron | DE | Oregon | 1963-67 |
| Snipes, Angelo | LB | West Georgia | 1986 |
| Snow, Justin | LS | Baylor | 2012 |
| Snowden, Jim | T | Notre Dame | 1965-70 |
| Soboleski, Joe | G | Michigan | 1949 |
| Sommer, Mike | B | Geo. Wash. | 1958-59, 1961 |
| Sommers, Jack | C | UCLA | 1947 |
| Spaight, Martrell | LB | Arkansas | 2015-17 |
| Spaniel, Frank | B | Notre Dame | 1950 |
| Sparks, Dave | G | South Carolina | 1954 |
| Spirida, John | E | St. Anselm's | 1939 |
| Springs, Shawn | CB | Ohio St. | 2004-08 |
| Sprinkle, Jeremy | TE | Arkansas | 2017-18 |
| Stacco, Ed | T | Colgate | 1948 |
| Stai, Brenden | G | Nebraska | 2002 |
| Stallings, Don | E | North Carolina | 1960 |
| Stallworth, Donté | WR | Tennessee | 2011 |
| Stanfel, Dick | G | San Francisco | 1956-58 |
| Stanley, Walter | WR | Mesa (CO) | 1990 |
| Starke, George | T | Columbia | 1973-84 |
| Stasica, Leo | B | Colorado | 1943 |
| Staton, Jim | T | Wake Forest | 1951 |
| Steber, John | G | Georgia Tech | 1946-50 |
| Steffen, Jim | DB | UCLA | 1961-65 |
| Stenn, Paul | T | Villanova | 1946 |
| Stensrud, Mike | DT | Iowa St. | 1989 |
| Stephens, Lenoard | TE | Howard | 2002 |
| Stephens, Louis | G | San Francisco | 1955-60 |
| Stephens, Rod | LB | Georgia Tech | 1995-96 |
| Steponovich, Mike | G | St. Mary's | 1933 |
| Stevens, Matt | S | Appalachian St. | 1998*00 |
| Stief, Dave | WR | Portland St. | 1983 |
| Stits, Bill | DB | UCLA | 1959 |
| Stock, Mark | WR | VMI | 1993 |
| Stokes, Fred | DE | Georgia Southern | 1989-92 |
| Stokes, Tim | T | Oregon | 1975-77 |
| Stone, Ken | S | Vanderbilt | 1973-75 |
| Stout, Pete | B | TCU | 1949-50 |
| Stoutmire, Omar | S | Fresno St. | 2005, 2007 |
| Stovall, Dick | C | Abilene Christian | 1949 |
| Stowe, Tyronne | LB | Rutgers | 1994 |
| Stralka, Clem | G | Georgetown | 1938-42, 1945-46 |
| Strickland, Fred | LB | Purdue | 1999 |
| Stuart, Jim | T | Oregon | 1938 |
| Stubblefield, Dana | DT | Kansas | 1998-00 |
| Sturt, Fred | G | Bowling Green | 1974 |
| Stynchula, Andy | DT | Penn St. | 1960-63 |
| Suisham, Shaun | K | Bowling Green | 2006-09 |
| Sulfsted, Alex | G | Miami (OH) | 2002 |
| Sullivan, John | C | Notre Dame | 2016 |
| Suminski, Dave | G | Wisconsin | 1953 |
| Sundberg, Nick | LS | California | 2010-18 |
| Sutton, Ed | B | North Carolina | 1957-59 |
| Sutton, Eric | CB | San Diego St. | 1996 |
| Swearinger, D.J. | S | South Carolina | 2017-18 |
| Sweeney, Walt | G | Syracuse | 1974-75 |
| Sykes, Bob | B | San Jose St. | 1952 |
| Symonette, Josh | S | Tennessee Tech | 2000 |
| Szafaryn, Len | T | North Carolina | 1949 |
| Szott, Dave | OL | Penn St. | 2001 |
| Sanchez, Mark | QB | USC | 2018 |
| Settle, Tim | DL | Virginia Tech | 2018 |
| Sims, Cam | WR | Alabama | 2018 |
| Smith, Alex | QB | Utah | 2018 |
| Smith, Marcus | LB | Louisville | 2018 |
| Stroman, Greg | CB | Virginia Tech |
